|
(More games & Books tests --> coming soon )
 |
Opening Book
tournament
with Fritz GUI |
| |
|
Logo
Homepage |
Tournament
Name |
Authors |
Tester Group |
Country |
 |
Opening Books |
Daniel Charles E.Ly |
Superleague |
 |
|
|
|
|
Engine testing condition |
|
Cpu |
GUI |
Opening Book |
Memory
total |
Memory
hash |
EGTB
(3-4-5??) |
EGTB
cache |
Time |
Tournament
type |
Round |
Total games |
|
Centrino 1.86 Ghz |
Fritz9 |
|
1 Gb |
64Mo |
|
|
3mn +1s >4 mn |
Gauntlet |
20 |
200 |
|
|
|
| more
Testing conditions : |
Takker tour III
beta , Fritz 9
book, The Turk book, my engine book, perfect 12
for all book optimize (defaults) if I don't talk
about the setting
- Takker tour III beta+ Fritz9 +perfect12= settings = optimization
(defaults)
- The Turk book settings (Djorge Vidanovic)
= min games = 1, up to moves 60 moves,
learning to 0%
- my engine book=min games = 1 ,up to 100 moves
learn= 0% :D
- my engine book is from .pgn games on
playchess.com with average elo 2750 engine room
|
| Chess
Engines : |
Toga II 1.2.1 |
| date: |
11-11-06 |
| Pgn
(link to your homepage or here) |
superleaguepgn (update
biweekly) + replay all game on replay zone (update biweekly) |
| Tester Homepage: |
superchessengine.com |
|
Results: |
Rating with Elostat
|
Rk |
LOGO/Book |
Author |
Mo |
W |
D |
L |
% Wh |
%Bl |
Total
% |
Pts W |
Pts B |
Pts
/80 |
elo |
|
1 |
TAKKER TOURIII |
Takker/W. Fuller |
360 |
33 |
36 |
11 |
79 |
49 |
64 |
31.5 |
19.5 |
51 |
+135 |
|
2 |
 |
|
12 |
24 |
39 |
17 |
61 |
48 |
54 |
24.5 |
19 |
43.5 |
+81 |
|
3 |
 |
Sedat Candaz |
60 |
19 |
37 |
24 |
56 |
38 |
47 |
22.5 |
15 |
37.5 |
+39 |
|
4 |
Fritz 9 book (commercial) |
|
|
13 |
46 |
21 |
51 |
39 |
45 |
20.5 |
15.5 |
36 |
+29 |
|
5 |
 |
Djordje Vidanovic |
26 |
16 |
32 |
32 |
49 |
31 |
40 |
19.5 |
12.5 |
32 |
0 |
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Takker Tour III beta : 2935 65 54 80 63.7 % 2837 45.0 %
2 Engine book : 2881 74 47 80 54.4 % 2851 48.8 %
3 Perfect 12 : 2839 49 76 80 46.9 % 2861 46.2 %
4 Fritz 9 book : 2829 41 74 80 45.0 % 2864 57.5 %
5 Turk book 1 : 2800 57 69 80 40.0 % 2871 40.0 %
Games : 200 (finished)
White Wins : 71 (35.5 %)
Black Wins : 34 (17.0 %)
Draws : 95 (47.5 %)
Unfinished : 0
White Perf. : 59.2 %
Black Perf. : 40.8 %
ECO A = 1 Games ( 0.5 %)
ECO B = 127 Games (63.5 %)
ECO C = 18 Games ( 9.0 %)
ECO D = 28 Games (14.0 %)
ECO E = 26 Games (13.0 %)
Individual statistics:
1 Takker Tourbook book : 2935 80 (+ 33,= 36,- 11), 63.8 %
Engine book : 20 (+ 4,= 11,- 5), 47.5 %
Perfect 12 : 20 (+ 10,= 9,- 1), 72.5 %
Turk book 1 : 20 (+ 12,= 6,- 2), 75.0 %
Fritz 9 book : 20 (+ 7,= 10,- 3), 60.0 %
2 Engine book : 2881 80 (+ 24,= 39,- 17), 54.4 %
Perfect 12 : 20 (+ 4,= 8,- 8), 40.0 %
Takker Tourbook book : 20 (+ 5,= 11,- 4), 52.5 %
Turk book 1 : 20 (+ 11,= 7,- 2), 72.5 %
Fritz 9 book : 20 (+ 4,= 13,- 3), 52.5 %
3 Perfect 12 : 2839 80 (+ 19,= 37,- 24), 46.9 %
Engine book : 20 (+ 8,= 8,- 4), 60.0 %
Takker Tourbook book : 20 (+ 1,= 9,- 10), 27.5 %
Turk book 1 : 20 (+ 6,= 8,- 6), 50.0 %
Fritz 9 book : 20 (+ 4,= 12,- 4), 50.0 %
4 Fritz 9 book : 2829 80 (+ 13,= 46,- 21), 45.0 %
Engine book : 20 (+ 3,= 13,- 4), 47.5 %
Perfect 12 : 20 (+ 4,= 12,- 4), 50.0 %
Takker Tourbook book : 20 (+ 3,= 10,- 7), 40.0 %
Turk book 1 : 20 (+ 3,= 11,- 6), 42.5 %
5 Turk book 1 : 2800 80 (+ 16,= 32,- 32), 40.0 %
Engine book : 20 (+ 2,= 7,- 11), 27.5 %
Perfect 12 : 20 (+ 6,= 8,- 6), 50.0 %
Takker Tourbook book : 20 (+ 2,= 6,- 12), 25.0 %
Fritz 9 book : 20 (+ 6,= 11,- 3), 57.5 %
|
|
Tester comments : |
I did some preliminary test and Takker III scored 75 to
80% vs medium strength opening book
(paradigm,Hs,Mix18,I-base,perfect9....). That s why I
took only the strongest book against Takker III beta. I
took perfect 12 because I was surprised by his strength
in the preliminary test, probably Sedat Candaz best book
ever that I test for Fritz GUI
William fuller (Takker) book is very strong, this
beta book won the book tournament. This book is very
impressive , scored 72.5 % perfect 12, 75% vs the Turk,
60 % vs Fritz9book. Really the strongest book I ever
tested for online games & blitz .
Engine book, I didn t expected that the book come
second ,Maybe it was lucky (because i m not an opening
book author and won't be). this a very small book only
12 Mo (100 % engines and probably 90% Rybka and average
2750 elo (online players) :D). Thanks to William & Dagh
(their 2 teams were finalist in the last Pal/Css) for
their advices and some strong online engine room players
for their .pgn. This book will be release probably end
December, beginning January. I will try to have a 20 Mo
opening book & tuned the book a little bit more.
Perfect 12 is a strong book, it only lose the
match vs Takker & draw strong book like Fritz 9 and The
Turk and of beat the engine book . If you didn t have
this book, I recommend you to download this good &
strong opening book. Probably the winner if Takker Book
didn t play this tourney
Fritz 9 is probably one of the best commercial
opening book. It scored well with white. We will see
soon if the Fritz 10 opening book is better .
The Turk book is a strong book. It was in the top 3
in my last 2 tournaments. It beat one more time Fritz 9
book and draw perfect 12, unfortunately it lost too much
points vs Takker & engine book. I was a little bit
disappointed because Pr Vidanovic book is one of my
favorite opening book.
|
|
|
|
|
Opening Book
with Fritz GUI |
| |
|
Logo
Homepage |
Tournament
Name |
Authors |
Tester Group |
Country |
|
|
Opening Books |
Daniel Charles E.Ly |
Superleague |
|
|
|
|
|
Engine testing condition |
|
Cpu |
GUI |
Opening Book |
Memory
total |
Memory
hash |
EGTB
(3-4-5??) |
EGTB
cache |
Time |
Tournament
type |
Round |
Total games |
|
Centrino 1.86 Ghz |
Fritz9 |
|
1 Gb |
64Mo |
|
|
3mn +1s >4 mn |
Gauntlet |
20 |
300 |
|
|
|
| more
Testing conditions : |
5 books .ctg + a no
book (Norm Pollock idea :D ) Takker tour II , Fritz 9
book, The Turk book, Paradigm, gen18, + secret=no book
for all book optimize (defaults) if I don't talk
about the setting
- Takker tour II+ Fritz9 = settings = optimization
(defaults)
- The Turk book settings (Djorge Vidanovic)
= min games = 1, up to moves 60 moves,
learning to 75%
- Paradigm settings (Dr Wael Deeb) = min games = 2
- Gen 18 (Norm Pollock) = min games = 8
|
| Chess
Engines : |
Toga II 1.2.1 |
| date: |
21-09-06 |
| Pgn
(link to your homepage or here) |
booktournament.rar |
| Tester Homepage: |
superchessengine.com |
|
Results: |
|
Rating with Elostat
|
Rk |
LOGO/Book |
Author |
Mo |
W |
D |
L |
% Wh |
%Bl |
Total
% |
Pts W |
Pts B |
Pts
/100 |
elo |
|
1 |
TAKKER TOUR |
Takker/W. Fuller |
235 |
37 |
52 |
11 |
68 |
58 |
63 |
34 |
29 |
63 |
+78 |
|
2 |
Fritz 9 book (commercial) |
|
|
33 |
52 |
15 |
58 |
60 |
59 |
29 |
30 |
59 |
+53 |
|
3 |
|
Djordje Vidanovic |
26 |
30 |
49 |
21 |
60 |
49 |
54.5 |
30 |
24.5 |
54.5 |
+27 |
|
4 |
 |
Dr wael Deeb
|
263 |
11 |
25 |
14 |
47 |
49 |
48 |
23.5 |
24.5 |
48 |
-11 |
|
5 |
 |
Norm Pollock |
265 |
22 |
51 |
27 |
51 |
44 |
47.5 |
25.5 |
22 |
47.5 |
-13 |
|
6 |
No Book |
|
|
6 |
44 |
50 |
37 |
19 |
28 |
18.5 |
9.5 |
28 |
-136 |
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Takker Tourbook book : 78 58 42 100 63.0 % -14 52.0 %
2 Fritz 9 book : 54 62 41 100 59.0 % -9 52.0 %
3 Turk book 1 : 27 66 42 100 54.5 % -4 49.0 %
4 Paradigm 1.0 : -10 41 69 100 48.0 % 3 50.0 %
5 Gen 18 : -13 40 68 100 47.5 % 4 51.0 %
6 Secret book : -136 53 52 100 28.0 % 29 44.0 %
Games : 300 (finished)
White Wins : 86 (28.7 %)
Black Wins : 65 (21.7 %)
Draws : 149 (49.7 %)
Unfinished : 1198
White Perf. : 53.5 %
Black Perf. : 46.5 %
ECO A = 28 Games ( 9.3 %)
ECO B = 199 Games (66.3 %)
ECO C = 19 Games ( 6.3 %)
ECO D = 20 Games ( 6.7 %)
ECO E = 34 Games (11.3 %)
Individual statistics:
1 Takker Tourbook book : 78 100 (+ 37,= 52,- 11), 63.0 %
Fritz 9 book : 20 (+ 5,= 9,- 6), 47.5 %
Turk book 1 : 20 (+ 7,= 11,- 2), 62.5 %
Gen 18 : 20 (+ 6,= 12,- 2), 60.0 %
Secret book : 20 (+ 10,= 10,- 0), 75.0 %
Paradigm 1.0 : 20 (+ 9,= 10,- 1), 70.0 %
2 Fritz 9 book : 54 100 (+ 33,= 52,- 15), 59.0 %
Turk book 1 : 20 (+ 5,= 9,- 6), 47.5 %
Gen 18 : 20 (+ 6,= 14,- 0), 65.0 %
Takker Tourbook book : 20 (+ 6,= 9,- 5), 52.5 %
Secret book : 20 (+ 9,= 10,- 1), 70.0 %
Paradigm 1.0 : 20 (+ 7,= 10,- 3), 60.0 %
3 Turk book 1 : 27 100 (+ 30,= 49,- 21), 54.5 %
Fritz 9 book : 20 (+ 6,= 9,- 5), 52.5 %
Gen 18 : 20 (+ 7,= 7,- 6), 52.5 %
Takker Tourbook book : 20 (+ 2,= 11,- 7), 37.5 %
Secret book : 20 (+ 9,= 10,- 1), 70.0 %
Paradigm 1.0 : 20 (+ 6,= 12,- 2), 60.0 %
4 Paradigm 1.0 : -10 100 (+ 23,= 50,- 27), 48.0 %
Fritz 9 book : 20 (+ 3,= 10,- 7), 40.0 %
Turk book 1 : 20 (+ 2,= 12,- 6), 40.0 %
Gen 18 : 20 (+ 6,= 11,- 3), 57.5 %
Takker Tourbook book : 20 (+ 1,= 10,- 9), 30.0 %
Secret book : 20 (+ 11,= 7,- 2), 72.5 %
5 Gen 18 : -13 100 (+ 22,= 51,- 27), 47.5 %
Fritz 9 book : 20 (+ 0,= 14,- 6), 35.0 %
Turk book 1 : 20 (+ 6,= 7,- 7), 47.5 %
Takker Tourbook book : 20 (+ 2,= 12,- 6), 40.0 %
Secret book : 20 (+ 11,= 7,- 2), 72.5 %
Paradigm 1.0 : 20 (+ 3,= 11,- 6), 42.5 %
6 Secret book : -136 100 (+ 6,= 44,- 50), 28.0 %
Fritz 9 book : 20 (+ 1,= 10,- 9), 30.0 %
Turk book 1 : 20 (+ 1,= 10,- 9), 30.0 %
Gen 18 : 20 (+ 2,= 7,- 11), 27.5 %
Takker Tourbook book : 20 (+ 0,= 10,- 10), 25.0 %
Paradigm 1.0 : 20 (+ 2,= 7,- 11), 27.5 %
|
|
Tester comments : |
Takker tourbook won again the book tournament . this
is the 3 rd time for Takker Tourbook (1 with Vigi
Varkley+ 2 with superchessengine :D ) and good
news , this book is free :D
Fritz 9 tournament book is a good book , It finished
2nd ... However , F9 book is not free .It scored well
with the 2 colors .
The Turk Book is a excellent book for online
tournament , it was doing good against F9 book (52.5%)
Paradigm was neither bad or good with each color ...
It could be a solid book for long time control
Gen 18 was doing good, just 0.5 pts behind paradigm
!!! No super killer move, it looks like solid for an
opening book, even if gen18 with white side is
slightly better than with black side
A simple remark with "No Opening book" don't expect
to win against a strong opening book :D
Thanks to all opening books authors who spent time to
hand tuned the book and to offer free opening book to
chess engine fans. |
|
|
some test results
|
Testing
Condition
for each book
Engine
Toga II 1.2.1a
Time 2+1
Games 40
for each book
HT
64
EGTB
none
GUI
Book Option :
Var of Play
optimize
Influ.Learn Value Maxi
Learn
Strenght 0
Minimum Game 3
Up to Move 35
If your book is better with other GUI book option I will
change his setting for next tournament
|
|
Rk |
Book |
LOGO |
Author |
Mo |
W |
D |
L |
% Wh |
%Bl |
Total
% |
|
Pts W |
Pts B |
Pts
/40 |
elo |
|
|
TourbookII |
TAKKER TOUR |
Takker |
235 |
15 |
17 |
8 |
68% |
50% |
59% |
|
13.5 |
10 |
23.5 |
+45 |
|
|
Turk Book for Rybka 1.0
|
|
Djordje Vidanovic |
26 |
13 |
20 |
7 |
73% |
43% |
58% |
|
14.5 |
8.5 |
23 |
+37 |
|
|
I-Base 2
|
 |
Dr Wael Deeb
|
75 |
12 |
16 |
12 |
52.5% |
48% |
50% |
|
10.5 |
9.5 |
20 |
-2 |
|
|
HS big Book
|
 |
Harry Schnapp
|
130 |
5 |
27 |
8 |
55% |
38% |
46% |
|
11 |
7.5 |
18.5 |
-17 |
|
|
Perfect 9.0
|
 |
Sedat Candaz
|
62 |
8 |
14 |
18 |
45% |
30% |
38% |
|
9 |
6 |
15 |
-63 |
Tournament result + .pgn to download (
openingbook3.rar )
with bayeselo (from Remy
Coulom )
Rank Name Elo + - games score oppo. draws
1 Takker Tourbook book 45 69 67 40 59% -11 43%
2 Turk book 1 37 67 66 40 58% -9 50%
3 I-Base 2 -2 68 68 40 50% 0 40%
4 HS big book -17 63 63 40 46% 4 68%
5 Perfect 9 -63 69 72 40 38% 16 35%
|
likelihood-of-superiority matrix (with bayeselo from remy
Coulom)
Ta Tu I- HS Pe
Takker Tourbook book 56 80 88 97
Turk book 1 43 76 84 96
I-Base 2 19 23 61 86
HS big book 11 15 38 80
Perfect 9 2 3 13 19
|
First test
|
Testing
Condition
for each book
Engine
Toga II 1.2.1a
Time 2+1
Games
100
HT
64
EGTB
none
GUI
Book Option :
Var of Play
optimize
Influ.Learn Value Maxi
Learn
Strenght 0
Minimum Game 3
Up to Move 35
If your book is better with other GUI book option I will
change his setting for next tournament
|
|
Rank |
Book |
LOGO |
Author |
Mo |
Win |
Draw |
Lose |
% |
>elo |
|
|
HS big Book
|
|
Harry Schnapp
|
130 |
+17 |
=46 |
_37 |
40% |
|
|
|
TourbookII |
TAKKER TOUR |
Takker |
235 |
+37 |
=46 |
_17 |
60% |
+70 elo |
Tournament result + .pgn to download (hsbigbookvstakkertour.rar)
with bayeselo (from Remy
Coulom )
Rank Name Elo + - games score oppo. draws
1 Takker Tourbook book 45 69 67 40 59% -11 43%
2 Turk book 1 37 67 66 40 58% -9 50%
3 I-Base 2 -2 68 68 40 50% 0 40%
4 HS big book -17 63 63 40 46% 4 68%
5 Perfect 9 -63 69 72 40 38% 16 35%
|
|
likelihood-of-superiority
matrix (with bayeselo from remy Coulom)
Ta Tu I- HS Pe
Takker Tourbook book 56 80 88 97
Turk book 1 43 76 84 96
I-Base 2 19 23 61 86
HS big book 11 15 38 80
Perfect 9 2 3 13 19
|
|
We will test these
books and maybe more if you have a special book to share
Rules (Could
evolve )
Same engine on
each side
No limit for the
book (size,Detph ... ), Maximum optimisation
Commercial book
could take part to the tournament .( I will add them later my F9 and
others )
Only one book per
author (the best one)
You could send us
your book tournament results . We will publish them if under our
rules .We need .pgn and your testing condition.
Book tested will
have a rank, points,% win ,% draw ,% Loss
If the author update
to a better and new opening book, the new one will take the place . (and
his rating will start from the start ...because 2 books could be completely
different !!! )
If you have
recommendation to optimize and to use your opening book, I will
follow your advices
I reserved the
right to modify the rules if I see some problem.
If you want we test your book .ctg
just contact me to know how to send your book for testing .
If you want we test your book .ctg just contact me to know how to
send your book for testing .
These are very good Book , Thanks to all these Fabulous Book Author
to make them Free .
If you know some other free Books .CTG,.abk,.bin .... to Test
contact us , We will test them .
|
